From mboxrd@z Thu Jan 1 00:00:00 1970 Received: from sog-mx-4.v43.ch3.sourceforge.com ([172.29.43.194] helo=mx.sourceforge.net) by sfs-ml-3.v29.ch3.sourceforge.com with esmtp (Exim 4.76) (envelope-from ) id 1YLyFA-0005pP-UQ for bitcoin-development@lists.sourceforge.net; Thu, 12 Feb 2015 18:12:05 +0000 Received-SPF: pass (sog-mx-4.v43.ch3.sourceforge.com: domain of riseup.net designates 198.252.153.129 as permitted sender) client-ip=198.252.153.129; envelope-from=justusranvier@riseup.net; helo=mx1.riseup.net; Received: from mx1.riseup.net ([198.252.153.129]) by sog-mx-4.v43.ch3.sourceforge.com with esmtps (TLSv1:AES256-SHA:256) (Exim 4.76) id 1YLyF9-0006My-H4 for bitcoin-development@lists.sourceforge.net; Thu, 12 Feb 2015 18:12:04 +0000 Received: from berryeater.riseup.net (berryeater-pn.riseup.net [10.0.1.120]) (using TLSv1 with cipher ECDHE-RSA-AES256-SHA (256/256 bits)) (Client CN "*.riseup.net", Issuer "COMODO RSA Domain Validation Secure Server CA" (verified OK)) by mx1.riseup.net (Postfix) with ESMTPS id 5DA95416CD for ; Thu, 12 Feb 2015 18:11:56 +0000 (UTC) Received: from [127.0.0.1] (localhost [127.0.0.1]) (Authenticated sender: justusranvier) with ESMTPSA id E067842A71 Received: from [192.168.202.127] (unknown [192.168.202.127]) (using TLSv1.2 with cipher ECDHE-RSA-AES128-GCM-SHA256 (128/128 bits)) (No client certificate requested) by nobelium.whale.ddns.net (Postfix) with ESMTPSA id 8F1A1DB806 for ; Thu, 12 Feb 2015 12:11:33 -0600 (CST) Message-ID: <54DCECE4.3020802@riseup.net> Date: Thu, 12 Feb 2015 18:11:48 +0000 From: Justus Ranvier MIME-Version: 1.0 To: bitcoin-development@lists.sourceforge.net References: <20150212064719.GA6563@savin.petertodd.org> <356E7F6E-300A-4127-9885-2183FB1DE447@gmail.com> In-Reply-To: <356E7F6E-300A-4127-9885-2183FB1DE447@gmail.com> OpenPGP: id=EAD9E623; url=http://pgp.mit.edu/pks/lookup?op=get&search=0x2A5FDA70EAD9E623 Content-Type: multipart/mixed; boundary="------------020806020003070609090405" X-Virus-Scanned: clamav-milter 0.98.5 at mx1 X-Virus-Status: Clean X-Spam-Score: -1.6 (-) X-Spam-Report: Spam Filtering performed by mx.sourceforge.net. See http://spamassassin.org/tag/ for more details. -1.5 SPF_CHECK_PASS SPF reports sender host as permitted sender for sender-domain -0.0 RCVD_IN_DNSWL_NONE RBL: Sender listed at http://www.dnswl.org/, no trust [198.252.153.129 listed in list.dnswl.org] -0.0 SPF_HELO_PASS SPF: HELO matches SPF record -0.0 T_RP_MATCHES_RCVD Envelope sender domain matches handover relay domain -0.0 SPF_PASS SPF: sender matches SPF record -0.1 DKIM_VALID_AU Message has a valid DKIM or DK signature from author's domain 0.1 DKIM_SIGNED Message has a DKIM or DK signature, not necessarily valid -0.1 DKIM_VALID Message has at least one valid DKIM or DK signature 0.0 UNPARSEABLE_RELAY Informational: message has unparseable relay lines X-Headers-End: 1YLyF9-0006My-H4 Subject: Re: [Bitcoin-development] replace-by-fee v0.10.0rc4 X-BeenThere: bitcoin-development@lists.sourceforge.net X-Mailman-Version: 2.1.9 Precedence: list List-Id: List-Unsubscribe: , List-Archive: List-Post: List-Help: List-Subscribe: , X-List-Received-Date: Thu, 12 Feb 2015 18:12:05 -0000 This is a multi-part message in MIME format. --------------020806020003070609090405 Content-Type: text/plain; charset=utf-8 Content-Transfer-Encoding: 7bit -----BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE----- Hash: SHA256 On 02/12/2015 05:24 PM, Oleg Andreev wrote: > >> I think that is a misdirection on your part. The point of >> replace-by-fee is to make 0-confirms reliably unreliable. >> Currently people can "get away" with 0-confirms but it's only >> because most people arent actively double spending, and when they >> do it is for higher value targets. Double spend attacks are >> happening a lot more frequently than is being admitted here, >> according to Peter from work with various clients. >> >> Like single address reuse, people have gotten used to something >> which is bad. Generally accepting 0-conf is also a bad idea(tm) >> and instant confirmation solutions should be sought elsewhere. >> There are already interesting solutions and concepts: >> greenaddress for example, and CHECKLOCKTIMEVERIFY micropayment >> channels for example. Rather than supporting and promoting risky >> 0-confirms, we need to spend time on better alternative solutions >> that will work for everyone and not during the honeymoon phase >> where attackers are fewer. > > Here's value-free assessment of the issue here: > > 1. Zero-conf txs are unsafe. 2. We'd all want to have a safer > instant payments solution if possible. 3. As a social artifact, > today zeroconf txs happen to work for some people in some > situations. 4. Replace-by-fee will break #3 and probably hasten > development of #2. > > The discussion boils down to whether we should make #2 happen > sooner by breaking remnants of #3 sooner. > > I personally would rather not break anything, but work as fast as > possible on #2 so no matter when and how #3 becomes utterly broken, > we have a better solution. This implies that I also don't want to > waste time debating with Peter Todd and others. I want to be ready > with a working tool when zeroconf completely fails (with that patch > or for some other reasons). > > TL;DR: those who are against the patch are better off building a > decentralized clearing network rather than wasting time on debates. > When we have such network, we might all want this patch to be used > for all the reasons Peter has already outlined. You've left out of the discussion that many (or all) proposed solutions for 2 either reduce privacy, or security, or both. That fact should not be ignored or swept under the rug. There's also no mention of the degree to which child-pays-for-parent achieves the stated aims of the original proposal (clearing mempool of stuck transactions, increasing payee assurance of conformation) without introducing incentives to double spend or forcing people into privacy/security sacrifices. - -- Support online privacy by using email encryption whenever possible. Learn how here: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bakOKJFtB-k -----BEGIN PGP SIGNATURE----- iQIcBAEBCAAGBQJU3OzkAAoJECpf2nDq2eYjDM8P/1a4bNa5s0ryMZHBxyhGcVk5 6hTSPpUF2/Y81JaC/EqzH8MMKqnPVcLxoikKoO5tIUxeo5bwC5OO8YyGk4NrpeCM HTmROR+4XFOULi1dsUs5LP5oBQ+sPu1uNOZKn2fPCgtkO0xj8/w3mCdlVlf7g+v4 bYt6rSmSCzyCY0qFQVYvyBoYeSVt6icdz45D54BvyNsEtlT+HvbNdG/SznT7QsLF 2rOZezp5zbIyhbhaV5KtCKwYzATFYr0nWFHVnBkYWcOY3mJdPg6zODUO5ocbGs45 RHEB8KMsKtrD+gnCwCoSb+J6TNlA8y//ilKemPb+gRSVVM1JJpHBwv7fc8jUu2Ap V9YNKOVOrmoGb5X2sCctAZ6474p8HCUgZh50OluQph01tGtq3uC1djJUvnVCP232 FQD47AU2LhU3wPjWSGEDIGtpeAk91+6huRCzv600xnIISd5KpryKpD6qWC3M4MGs G4omAZhHjW5/E8CO/CH21nbPA2P1wozrGE5N8UTc2kwias/4Vn+v3IedjnSiS+IF n37MzlyCVs9qXyT7WylT4UAnc9exxHwGXKrvcCUaIAw7FOFEHjiHYLjZFIrVWmpM 7qxjMD/yM3kDmd/+YxCbITAERsHh04k4PITLVbnOyXY+axi+Xuow9v5HvwqERvt8 XjbkwrkFIuKfUJyfIuR+ =ony0 -----END PGP SIGNATURE----- --------------020806020003070609090405 Content-Type: application/pgp-keys; name="0xEAD9E623.asc" Content-Transfer-Encoding: 7bit Content-Disposition: attachment; filename="0xEAD9E623.asc" -----BEGIN PGP PUBLIC KEY BLOCK----- mQINBFSjxPgBEACn6XzXmGNn3Tn5tBHxCsTceU42c0H5Ww7tCQRw6zhaYhd6S/Ki gjGQ0rZDEiyalOQdgvazW7DKO/dOz20+UzK6RLJfTQaSqCnwEMhzC8RO82Xi/bR0 HjBoHPqFwM4UEauOoTao5vQqSN0IzMSGCvsJU/IADIkERsUfgJLjcHR/aXkuzPGJ Ijg4SloA0emfed6Oi6aUcccs+rCtL2nCLtRlPstrkyS59cr/8bIL6aK26Xag7bkY AOtwWjtvRufOCB+ZnRnBtoVL1Tje020hQirqUFe/IJG/M6tJadCJIdYE8aFQznSn uOUYHf30CY3cSuYMa0PvC+18EWLr7AnqolkRjYGFB0n7oM8CPmJ5XvbVb+qc4FMR cEPoGv31DprsPSktmd58zS35NE0qjM2Bk8u7IB3HgtdRKKWrJVcyG1/ooFFGKdXt NVDv1HJKhcYAiW98UL4jL2YJTxAxsksEYrHG9tu63cyANcX6u8rxD/HkRHtEM4vM jUDz+fAGA4ARqc+II3bYxTCekxzeWEOLvcP3awuj1CXlR7vXVEc/cZcliukAopco 3xJaRuO77vefNhcD+eoQvt7fzUkI+04kFdsAA+uPEM6fW4Pt4Z22nAQnid7FYjir T4Jlw6rUkOHOeMA7RCuAnCeUehYzq8B9243QgtGVGO8Yf8/jMes1nKhaMwARAQAB tClKdXN0dXMgUmFudmllciA8anVzdHVzcmFudmllckByaXNldXAubmV0PokCPgQT AQIAKAIbAwYLCQgHAwIGFQgCCQoLBBYCAwECHgECF4AFAlSjx4IFCQHg/2gACgkQ Kl/acOrZ5iP5Tw//VB26Tgu45tccySHvjBx+hYbVvkX4N2tr/rcE2eZ93+qguay7 ci4ZXfWDnJFff++IozrdgjCrkinRy9RMSzDbmToLkLNuydzJgDWjjnqUK94h53Dh Mh2oBuwlMUq682ZxIaccN9ZBCS8tmB5v1/7J46e3cgbVOnikUn5uP1EjudBhjsCP bsq+WEd6tF+2L4FFYwSjaUKXjchmnQhdboJKK3RofhDiAia3MMj2nncvlr/Z8eIe rD4gmri8Z21iGX9TN+kqNh7QiUVYHTsGM4dQ0KxtzUysj86qLOWc1FwoRVtAxMLH iOHtm/jhOE/nEMJdpZ39g2AqPasBZU11pkpIy0HlL8adW4XVktSEH226+ejxhoot 6bzbJdKofBfGjkOe8pfFqGQY62EQ2bZaCjZ9xsLx8ruVBJSxDawAfVHdDz357UXl LLWCJJlVu5FN24wnTwS8FKAZQ+DuuzzgxaKK/1dXenDOw2CjTE9AvAKYuWkJ6O3W CR1LzUMehPupbxP7zetgX44wM1kba6A2XRjpqRVrruZ+Lmr6foXi3nlpkUL3yOuC fO8lIeEXen5ZhMwkwWxglImlT/OFD9iDpklb4Klt6HBN9iBNbtv03STeZYpj3M34 3AmNejOC9VC071mop2F1XdF39OKWjbBfQWT1yvg+hWEmk1YkQ2tWlC6eteeJAj4E EwECACgFAlSjxPgCGwMFCQHhM4AGCwkIBwMCBhUIAgkKCwQWAgMBAh4BAheAAAoJ ECpf2nDq2eYjjO0P/iMWbM1rU876yxMIaPiq5Pqh1HoOeYXDnr2hdrn4cJqamQgJ E+fiUhSLRRjLUs9qhxjwiYL8mGq8rNk5hbJE38i7DE5Mc5syGfdeuuQBkbQSu9xb 1ygCHFX0x/Ktlp6UHh/E2HD5+IFFmqqDWNZNXcoY7ct5SI8BJUAmQCl90+3RXTos JQhGScqblLOKHWOhP/xsDXMmWgwk0jH2ZUH9NZOUNanjbXSypfxeD6z95TxXxeaK 2D//SDte+e36BtsSQGTW8PrhN5pwGbScTLepvt272UBNYPTUkL7qnRU2jP3BAQpg VeEvDeIG6xbR15nkOs3EPUS12yQKrLx7rUti9xnzEZ0YmvLrwaal9aaiujrvqAcE 3vtJb0hgsUH3pQ6Ay7kf/xKu/EV3DQ/juaX5RSnbODbPSCBmRr8NbbTihFE32g7a 5H41adBkeGKIiU/xQ6SHuzUzOkRCpnB1o4SvyKsLyAJi73Nbq6tkHP1aIkVAJ2e8 BoZmR51AjaoFJgXDe/lWCxKs3vd8KgO9tivPMijyeeetAlZqKb8tp/oiWj2v2Iv0 PiME8wsP/7KLgE4i8UCnvwQIP+cVm6rkpCvmeif6BjI3COVBCAJm+p4d6MYD9Bh/ 9nWnWUX2jBc6Bji/kLl+GUYuTmmMUTqia0rucB9QjJVbyMK3gOKno3/T+D8WiQIf BBABAgAJBQJUo8ckAgcAAAoJENA4LRC2Ds/SdLwP/ipvNal+ACfRb/2fCKXrBWWe vOmGJ7kRKlOzxYdkhs0hS8V5DmuutFsPmM3B2lmkKmHvljDYhrOCADO0CB5a9+Jc zSbCOx03ZdRasw0J4D7ulG+rEfUPEDuLpUB0SHsqmxp+F7X8hmHoUrOd/zHo9cP+ MpqcdzEY3K5FdJSyX2QY1m6L5qn/zR1Bxjt1qWnuDAUYijHq32Z5/4pxztrNLGnf /EkEcuhnDxdijrVYmZl8KjUqpl22AGOavA+fN+qQXsyxX4aQ/2JC3VaY61yr1LY2 EAo6dwMj9igmWHgiZXra347CfQYm2OKC8mbL9ADvIIwHvVmoYgWH2g/t/7YoQd0F Vlh8YBUikIgyxqJUspYPlUT5XTpRCgQL8R2Q3iY9RSsf56oQgvaxGb0Ym8P9jK+I iOliBVsgn02Hmf1hq43mLiaDOQXLgqexe/NBdNL/7RX5cLty3Gq6pKZmUexzi+ST fECMFBD2pCQyuAKoTQS+ZOF73E0A6uv3Zw1y/SffkiPB5TYqOczOFPGTUAEQYi/a z58YWSJpxZ0Zq7bRBHhEFCLlIu/vUbfMNqHimcQH8gDEy/oVyNIC5SAqwiiUOei0 Tyhi8TefUX+YsTjhgIwfJYE5IFFjIOBfTTG39H04PY8hA8tLOYyCF/AdGpI7HJIR PkZxiO6zm5UmQ3nsBJdJiQJBBBMBAgArAhsDBgsJCAcDAgYVCAIJCgsEFgIDAQIe AQIXgAUJAeD/aAUCVKRgSQIZAQAKCRAqX9pw6tnmIw/DD/9Y993Yqk1Ip95J5pCq 3a5eNiHDQlQidM/s1qLMmCjWmeIYZu0JCabUYcOBc08fX1YJcVMJF/U37a2g8rC/ AcpZ/7q1WMtlQGss23B4E1WfypUvMExEztLK3zYax8za9JiehqNO3O1R17DiKVqA /Ag3t3CQXene2Ux+oLIp4s8zEOAbQIbvqyOlqk7iC8kB/AzhR1p2obcV4rzcUKCY X0h0CXyjFvZeN91q9c1qYlJ2urod06XbmiqwOl5+OeYoHymzixr6r5ZoHUQXXmb/ vVVHipjmYxX3iN8mPIM8BqwpsI2HWoFd/PjrJkrrilYYuQBzZtWfXDieeEaypEKl eJuvZVDTgi0wiJ5ooN2AkI+0/22/pFWOAX/kxnH675qUeAhKkWdXAWB1q0NPRw6W Mz4x7+CvH7dB5M4+eVFVDcwUbnMl4HUrEjbpk1bL0y/Sgl43FW9z7maHaArsT8pW rq0znLOEu7LPkNlAu346U9bO9h2aEg4vXNZ98z8oSq8eh63IDH7+pUgo19SOmK0U FsR0wDlpKcQY9/ScUGDhpl4BwE+AfYxySlEiPN9MUjxcWMeyjM9OkeMxBZHW4xgI O8IDc3plIcJoyDwJsu6n7szPSI/WQ4gyd4d1utv4yauvvPZUM8UQm4lrUvDBCu0F BUaFKCTfk5VY3isaT1ile9C+MIkBHAQQAQIABgUCVKRhjQAKCRDD97smOEUNtZjR B/9ubKi21C6pj4xAiI7/yJz028J4sksUHdE/Gb8RvJ0zEsQqhvPreAcySzmgky26 U1X9u5ZhDHvPU2UH8iLNRUO2SKg4pBgQNv2/BWI9QW0/CHG1Z+vXOg2dcEA9HZv9 JQaZEMg3MFtYpDEm66tEl334qlvwSWzZbLv9CnH/MBt366WJj/TSa4z7p499Cdmc qKGMYijZZS9RVYbA2CysX0FRlI0CXf3Nb4UROshTYBIf5i0hF9QAzKwkt7q6pcIq RjEb2TXFApCTFTD+4fEkC82AFvR/DJW4h0yCkoswYTlAhdBs0yl+CIc3uNMg6C1v jSsm3dJSjAex1tfCRNCrfgy/tChKdXN0dXMgUmFudmllciA8anVzdHVzcmFudmll ckBnbWFpbC5jb20+iQI/BBMBAgApBQJUpGA9AhsDBQkB4P9oBwsJCAcDAgEGFQgC CQoLBBYCAwECHgECF4AACgkQKl/acOrZ5iMjoA/+KQg/k74BE1i0ucGovGRkUFnf 4UTv+jpNWPtODazWlqlXjILvPAtQ09izXG/2cPMNgyVpHQsD7inc5+uZKRhix7lO sL5/pKZIy6ak4GpWZokZG/dzUeOzchrKW3S7QlDzmdCv20huJsgNHO2bQwMQsivY pO3yFxK7vF9Oe8ZyB9AwzgDgK6DZS2LU0d8mNGL5Dn7RQQC3ikqSVc7fIUjTiF8f ZPxMRMcU7h5ud8HzTHxKvCcPFRrndq/pY1OWF+c5io46wvC0T3Iy/gxfl0EX6RX/ YRB9vqJBrn08CBeUtOVa34pWZf3kGGyH5Fblnhz4UTHoQtsu4LNXjb6rFOJskqFq sd4bkzVgz3CvLNOLPJkNQ9TK4RRvu0t2dtRld+oLx5wD/FHZwZBPtlRq/ye3wwOc QymXPqAWixCUlL32UdpBTozcjhU66IiQoeMrIWCrueYZFEU0nO6AgZkwN5Afy1WO Z6wytzS2uL7sX+JK118eAmzgUfXO6mQL/J8QKS/ozlFf1eRtv7YMB2GOuhfzDbEG gmOwai8fqpQue4IbTl+Go21iXJ/f4dFCUN5ly0kYTft3wazuQ4joyO8DGk0RDwuO hhV2u6pL31xcNGxsttf3hspzoMEOS38C5PCESH2qHCkHPN0Ki0mutYoaV3uE/g3z 2hi/4ruwNr7AmDRb8buJARwEEAECAAYFAlSkYY0ACgkQw/e7JjhFDbVjzggAtzyd pzwMrGxbSlOpdHxC/EaqwnSisN9p/e7DeWSKQ5mdtZELNr50wubZocqPYH0RauBg m2xjgyfjj1RWL5dOfvryV5bgR3hVgHNxfm1VjsniD8ku+cfPFewRfg/t5j04j/Jk AFd/oBNhy/KdT7Qy5p6qkYRhjJky223lyvYlxcIzLoV4+drGMOyu09JmQrWPCuRT DCocHeamyBnDBXctk9FbCGA8512WDbxuCP885HvW3Xjao57Bbf0bSeNnYz8+QLqk PS0vMkiVxLE2mBD03MBSLZeC9yudp/IUEQ5qB6mPlmCuyBrfhg6FKGDldKQjSCaG uiPuXs05pbcw3ipmn7QnSnVzdHVzIFJhbnZpZXIgPGp1c3R1c0Bsb2NhbGhvc3Qu bG9jYWw+iQI/BBMBAgApBQJUpGCzAhsDBQkB4P9oBwsJCAcDAgEGFQgCCQoLBBYC AwECHgECF4AACgkQKl/acOrZ5iN4nRAAgTzxFgf65X46/tsjG3s83JALfMsKileA jJjFxfhdXvqqj1tDuL1mF4ocyTLgro8N+E7dAPu7gA8bJnYJZGzgavJmlEj6Tqgs WaKXurE8zfmnDLpzB+SJU1dwUXr7qr26zPZgl5Xo5lqC6aVxKlKSCopaW9r94VV7 0blqO7TdMgOnPKyow0S02jIbNLkBoIxYJ+IYKoYSW1bXO+TUqy3hjMQuTqDNBv0u Qy7kGlCDiWbXEt6aQQBbBeQzher5BQr+ReFG+zjbAmD9UL87R/VOT00FDZzA2c7o tdKoraWdycx3fu/SxDeTcSPK/zJwO9Jz0lDJGndNVMW81bAgLHlqYsnay/gc8Jy7 bDeEhTqHOguen3UFcfUdgOqpRBH7GMhSpRfmk66eUluTXNSzmmf87R6V+yPT4n+F TNQqqahpC7a6XSDXsBVRsY1DSH7TMNv5UovSyq4pyGtqV75ZhgbBfCqWTO2thOgt aUll1TTYjslB1TKkfZbzKuBQ5NtsN11eQL+cs7ryWuIAE/qz34tymdOWHgeV24p6 fZ3+tDfCM1WfgFRd/XnfJbfymvHxnaIoEfKRobxJAR5eJaFnzMOH5DISpY/JeBor RqBaSYe/GVIJM9vfqJGDgt/OclS7+6uwH/kli58sUMGDpCL00XwVUCntdETproKM s992jbTnkIiJARwEEAECAAYFAlSkYY0ACgkQw/e7JjhFDbV55wf/dTK5KoXcBI9Q 0CVGrrxlSO2cxdYzFcpS1xPeqaBSeLEm1IHWOA8yE2vBWX7jzhN9jgR3arBNKaCT 9697Pb1AVInNT7WiNhq9PlyxKKq+vwYlZ2ULEAo6LIj8nPtxeDX68do7/iKI6sO/ SssNxn3PAqpVJ9IrmPXZ06VrPZ7tNoeTtADtpNNPim4BkKNDCmKOfBmLfou9UV8i 6Om5prG6zpxRsruMglgD4gLYKQy9K8QGTyP8QCV+PY9BvK7j3YkK1XlcGjSLlkGF 89gseSZylBfWEU22SpV8OBCrGB+uCPaX221jFH4lXLE9byr31OijjEQ+wk1dLHYj zjclOISpEbQqSnVzdHVzIFJhbnZpZXIgPGp1c3R1c3JhbnZpZXJAaTJwbWFpbC5v cmc+iQI/BBMBAgApBQJUpGDLAhsDBQkB4P9oBwsJCAcDAgEGFQgCCQoLBBYCAwEC HgECF4AACgkQKl/acOrZ5iMKjQ//UgoXAjSqQPONBrpG2Mz8/DlwdkIk4zsmtCrC uugfKRN1b1w8BmtDg5A2cFByTTH/uwoaIjHV0nAT7GIoC9wymwG6XDoxQufbjIQg H9k5Rfv6gShVzlCnvUMMhjoAl6mweQcoaDdHYwiSAltJRxW1FC2wdNykoE7X4A2R dvd8AuNuoPKKYFmA2D7vRxScTZ2jFvzWOnnyqf1uaOfBWgcwd7cetARdB7EgkK3M Sr86Ld7vulVsTvJiwKhnGISi2NGh7nhEIpDGXxDHHnKGBRJWWInDn2fkOYuddroE 1Xnd7R11ti7LKv4s83CLAg+eHdHfV4+EPbw1PNIov9bKUj/yIA7eZy7n//laljBB d98TuOGHPGKsv7bRi5rgnIgJLLbUosHfQBjd1xEmsG9BM/6lzmQKqUv3c66+Bwfr nRztlZEx0biqosc2LJn+NPPen9N87B6wg5yhZeAthkVtP+Jcr838aCgAwam9jugu tuVU+a5oonlLVrPMLwEO9XfI+mqDKiwbhIa/YaKy+cMIm+GoQs73OXBV1rPWW4kV m/I31v/qIgXZ+nEoLImrotE14HOi7+fPeWrmByQLHzh0Mbs3qxJAi0bgynn4ZBa5 Qm5vTHn6l6zTZNZfgSY6mAaYKt4uYhihMhyrYyVHwsscTiJ+hdu2D6ke4hBC+arx YG5BFzaJARwEEAECAAYFAlSkYY0ACgkQw/e7JjhFDbUEKQgA02GzIFvqv0acOQ4N fk7BXM5w35ikeQ5kUEkk9neRq/ppxzfekhPUu1/68qFZr3V+qjD+i02vvBgqcWkP bOYr7O3AUWAuyBmmxpebJLKLd1fqkH7suwOMGzK/m6d6LxkJBNuLGoPa+GR4FBhw Vub2/KlpbxpXRQke6vEjHv+vujm9dBnRWerQbsDNCISgwfiPh/kyawZ5V1fm0pBk H0G1SuBq2WXbW4PK8OP+HOcUWlRuFVynXAtkpvh77BGFcuIe3KmSxzX0JIMxJL47 Szi93rHO+YE4Y6ENPrmc0eXuY/1t0PybvOo99IKGMYjxImg2ajx71tsZ1EsxfFFf hqEPl7QnSnVzdHVzIFJhbnZpZXIgPGp1c3R1c3JhbnZpZXJAbWFpbC5pMnA+iQI/ BBMBAgApBQJUpGDaAhsDBQkB4P9oBwsJCAcDAgEGFQgCCQoLBBYCAwECHgECF4AA CgkQKl/acOrZ5iORFA/9G++Ss2KOKnEaXtuMN4ga2rG1mNWweXRWS3khLt0XUzYi tV5CtEcctRzUG93uc/AK+Jx4mzdBRHWNYCQ0NDX9yb8tEfdbtLNzKFDCr/5/fhkP IT0OfP7/j6eFLP+KfcpDIEiffIspIiGT/NG35ORViV17QfaXOjzPtt7ZI5F2VYNg kDhZFvrcQgTEJJcxzzgLox6e3iIeixB2QPJRV8RRnEaAFmWo60WXKJ9lwTnZhP2o 67pPGeI/5xWxMJeS4I+bL478XC7fNGZbVSmbGlz0z2U6YHORZsHXQryr9MHd6lJD rsLPjWiuRR1DgEyWyXtX2CRvHUXU12BZm+V5sBzbf6wvDVJPhupgZuNynucvXk8O W+DrL6gIP+8FmnVH23+8dNlKXwcIsTS3PfLc0mQtA7XrZt3Z+uGUsqiS450848ax JdsWc6WYZR2mbB4hF/SppMtPpjhYL5TPK3+/c+/g8HO1rQ69NFMCWg8db8Uo7EyP 4OZsxl1u9fHbiYecyEAeg6JUaW80Es4jVt32uJUm8PZsOLqqMZHolp17K6vz7EEv iseFwMKUNruTz6yKSmlqiAQt138gnTQW42Q82t34GxyXUMSq640x3YOFkzGP6MqF FLt9e7xkf3J9TVyyauNoGDaLqcp71V0Zk8eaRS8/0COVtxNQKsTQ/RdJFTe0T7SJ ARwEEAECAAYFAlSkYY0ACgkQw/e7JjhFDbUYBwf/XtPwe7eRtCkyi/znB7MzW4MR EKPdR2IOvVKATrToepri39+bP9VFktCV+buPMGXgRTvMDgJ9a91AjJUXQ+j2q5XD uCuyG8Upc0cajNIXjFKudj3SYEXHbLYYs7707Qo2QLKh+sCysPJDbsWO6+rKvNv2 mwNr8tFogIWsFb0Kp3OiADd5fnZub8GprKQYuKAy2buT2KB+5VpisN2CV+AxPrzs j0sGmdD56jIMKKPiE9H3nuLF/ZbrrzVKYABcqfCorBV54Q4yDsjyj+r3WkquqwC8 jgmnvrrh3WYTJMI1uue/rJiIPdZZyb6FS3oUYsFN/WJgJi4s9lEHTKH+lwCiQ7Qj SnVzdHVzIFJhbnZpZXIgPGp1c3R1c0Btb25ldGFzLm5ldD6JAj8EEwECACkFAlSk YPICGwMFCQHg/2gHCwkIBwMCAQYVCAIJCgsEFgIDAQIeAQIXgAAKCRAqX9pw6tnm I6x/D/4zDT2pF5li1MsYxNYAOiM9P6QxWWI3keCb1ugUIsGEvcCv601AB7u20TWU rwQ97AQEQJc7DPIH3RtsnAsslm0iSFy1yGKKxjsZDAOsuotYSrmxTs3CWRaW1cXy lHMiB4yKsEXkoiMrF85tIPHA4CatpK1uLlOuTGj7jALupc21rj6+NhY//Pv+PlNO klXljTee8Bc96eUjsX4qOYOt5Hi1s7HSnQstLe4E5VLtxe6GUfFJnb8N6lmUprga qE5b3AGTRsKsHTdYVpHbvgaSN6SdnoFCGXK440y9kb4+QhV9CEt920B71/6sZPkE 3AJzHrFtIHgzzA0JNbgZrLhjl1g4uJxfXfg5dyUQ7I8FWlEg2vl+/AQT7MIkYHTm SPbvF6wql59S8reP0qWapSiogmaPUGkaFtS4Z8YVcA5UMDTbPxMnd0Z4TRUfGW4y UdZ1UzCkSw6UWdX3+WDwk0+ewHoXujATupa+ribXluSM67UtYCj8VYRS89kRmyTV 1KyWzoJ+D6n+sMi/0QEO3zyF6xcK6vD2T5usvXwbHUScCvDmlBeQQQPFtpj9KBmi wpQBNMf3mDbQ0QdpnT/kcNUIY5qexoLm1OjpLTcxP8nuvov+/STYCPGNKJmcTTv3 huMCb2xhCOShO5/rHxxyOnicJoJrLeJnGYm2wA7Wy5DnOBBwF4kBHAQQAQIABgUC VKRhjQAKCRDD97smOEUNtWoBCADHYn/bIvXAlzir4c/JzKIK1Nr6f2FnKKCIniwI Abn+GSsUL4dcKhnvp9EZHrmvcU2kr8LAL/9ilOtIlFpoIUiIOsUXj4mvw5XPz8Gj A4W2PiDCzJajFhbntFbM3LwL2tzrbFWBzmxuDoDVmNFmNnYAL4nP1n0hy8ctvEws 3YMxlWhGAkALJCq9uhmACXB6qCY9uVplsbPvtY1H3Pskl2eDHdtYcrnqIGxUsWBB hgBkcfLFhxHQUTuCNVn75bIe2Lpjo+IPC0rhDDZAKjTKzqMM+V1YYoYspAGD5iqD dvS4zd027PYYXBghdXvLSJaiR9lrhCoxBSHpSmQPfjnkv3G6tCtKdXN0dXMgUmFu dmllciA8anVzdHVzLnJhbnZpZXJAbW9uZXRhcy5uZXQ+iQI/BBMBAgApBQJUpGEE AhsDBQkB4P9oBwsJCAcDAgEGFQgCCQoLBBYCAwECHgECF4AACgkQKl/acOrZ5iPm Xw//WG45cntP5oQbB4Uf6yO0Nt56DOXm2T6RPNF1AZYmIVpE5tAbOhgY8XCL5auF h6eCpIij4wqxCyNGIlQihWUPcigoE3ZCCh5LnaVoHZm1fjKCewpsXsCtinA7x9sL F+32xTyAJxCiQtB7Gjm+3cVsmbPKHU8Nh2hJ99A65Udj3YwIpjXcStWncFw+EqLO 7vz2obu4xOhU+bHwEZeYVKplNlSCBh5psw32zHI5MqAbzNoPqdX7i/Y6eglui7Sr JkhIjwV2cGeY7VDmFMcRjgMH06SZYQ/x2+6TdVTfXyrnLu14LkZH6+AVmr1adgwt bQmEJ7poGqJPs7ij8gYHRWTITMG2EUds4MCPqhW0mgZWckA+KEPFZbfKJXyDpNZ5 cifPx/HSg9T3CPPkoSs5DsUePgaQvFtDil+04hcEIoBrnTz3/Ps4dYkeo8P8jJpn +4Rxlj1aATyp+LqoaUbFBaSB+JsGYsOIo7jwcp+wMiyWWXB6xR1XECAyRZERmbuG LZ7yphaR1/AxNfBSXx5NAroxUx6nZWfSOmLL9e92W7+7NDSE3UQS1rhENKZqkcbK +OpTprjAAVsl5aVuCK13kN/duoCYbfSrs4pqpujkho5t+FwZiMSe+l6d1vu6ADc3 ycFicdjw+ndELxM3tzOSSAiABw1jprGZ3qn9/oCMf5CFsS2JARwEEAECAAYFAlSk YY0ACgkQw/e7JjhFDbXLTgf+NNeBmPBeoM63qLDiikeySOWnCrb9/ZbRd7fU3JnO 88OKua4cLAmNiBfoiWIpH+r/qp7hNsWXVkDG5yUTeYR963ctF2SbQ5qioLKJ/dhi gITB31nNjxL66ShzsmIIW1oh+ZZoGE79F+Y4OX/uBBWOft70DfhCGtFtASbX+NqO bbFKIHlUHfljYtZ+lj0LwHBbkYuKm8h2v6xFkbdzadjp84uUuggu9/D7efdNZZkc 6gvlHwJaID3/ZTp5S3wDY7RB5GYFHSraJirG0DOKQzlP4O77djg1GJD8KToKqMjd AbpaoqVoGsuJbtIFXMcdx8vrxoKLfNUF/9aplPZydIn0obQ+SnVzdHVzIFJhbnZp ZXIgPEJNLTJjVGVwVnRaNkF5SkFzMlk4THBjdlpCOEtiZGFXTHdLcWNAYm0uYWRk cj6JAj8EEwECACkFAlSkYVgCGwMFCQHg/2gHCwkIBwMCAQYVCAIJCgsEFgIDAQIe AQIXgAAKCRAqX9pw6tnmI44dD/9i2TsYKxEZ0EBlhXZ1veVdb5BmL5aPAcqcKZsZ 3b4NL4o8CmxDNaE8K38UQlLKjnpd6iuwpHO1nMsgW1uIjHSYmVDRy8dguz815XJv 9dIJihFeeeiZUFVWgLNz9b5ioAHZeTsnwYGHKMUoSEzwR4eNjIsZie8gWk15wPYv F+txYWbD+Ma1bOJslY0L7ExTFSMWguhwh4MRni24nlhrxX1TckTa6xvCkE9S2hqV kGQOEYpU0LQmc/sriEcFmPVNlHTjrPQqcpEI0q3NWQecngpb6yykyh1z+aYfLPd4 WmPRUgL6tQimPwYwxvLWC3bAP8/D7ZioK3YMpr3zYhb+KcmV1gSFoxAeBhLApgMu 6+QAQYZs+GiVNhJ5tdFwMxEqfmXJKxqU34lRDm3CrjxkpEnXOuaz2Hbl8MPCNkxk adGaeJBpT5C3CS/gsIex1esK5ViHtAHjXbvRq3Y4K6uIYJik/+slpDD7osSACMdy /NOyP84ACBoYUsKIOki1R+MNVE7f3/OmFvrvxvSSIEwHhqUaRotE6gd/XpxYCxj3 y7cVd4PBOWGM9OkJejB/0cjidMjdfk4iKTd/S77F+6uQCGVRin8mWhFSFhp3jj+t i1K3FkdRqk27/e5Hih+Rw0oJIThhtNoKhMDfCvCb6yJiNmBdD1l5fPhK63Ll2qyV +ZETlYkBHAQQAQIABgUCVKRhjQAKCRDD97smOEUNtRSGCADidHfekz0mjRr450hG wnVYScf8Swvdo2ezo/e2mN0kjCbWlJfo3AnaJm3RJyZ9IDAKgmVZc+sQzs8NozBZ AtI96f5iQPjx3xZIJJgJF6NiWPuNVuUahx2jfq37UHSwquQkYhRJq2JBbJAzAiLu v4VV7vDYxgyNP9r6HnAtmgMoO9se+PjX4eVMhtUh5IIsg/qYUohwUdfEnz7dJ0ek 4m0D6FU8TF+7VWMWxAnZRri4lC0Pgiod9h6HSJxzq29qkq8/fAdOpa51usRYkxsB sBB5QFOOTYF/GYfiSxmWp8JUQ89ByCb0oNMQ7XaYkH4WLyT19qGK4u1JGXoXCrrt Y0f5uQINBFSjxPgBEADF3tkPOwjkPP50TdkrwNQmOfeKDi0pd4xQyECJuxtwefJc Fuwl3JC32a6RId7T/2SPCxQdGijVQKzxBcRK//2AVu/gSM91GKSqmWvPuDeYZSOc L6RnfGZb+vGOPq+GM488AykwAe1mAUW9kl90LdR5gDcyuXpyLmkB+XRe6gxXKTdf eDJn52nYfC3lbad2O7o+zr1OlszxAD6gLNFjI6cmr5H7m5M1F145ce9dugf5cEbf Gl5GysZZj+I2lbbTxIpqMdgr6T01AJYf+6py06sHOcOee5PjRHBgQ5PrE+R0rIHy hSbn2hsS8Rsc/nyvOTIEygdNp3NqvngmB7esZdJj9QSz6yF6lDZlzBtzyVtMcs4C FT08Q/q2zwDNIjXvkGo1y2+o+0cbKAs3tvivZCFbWhDU3SG+TMDrxDF5aKxc4VOQ hT/1KUCn6ABUVCtjveXWPAAkr/Ny4+Q/xCXTvN6fJCQCOxWGFQ/3U/y/9e4HIPek L6SeZDg7WrZGqB9VyYGexRNt2wthxPDLjnuTtP1UHXbzz/aeGw7LBfvdI583vvN8 VMte0qEeLK8hlB5rSSRk8OIoRDhuQ7GS1zQUcOEOYeBRBVvw/Qd3C7/5V9BBIgY/ ToAEHVQ3pmQ08DkNjtXn8Zz/H4CXFKBMYuXUWhHi4T0gcw0QjLq0Krx7mJxecwAR AQABiQIlBBgBAgAPBQJUo8T4AhsMBQkB4TOAAAoJECpf2nDq2eYjKTAP/Rutq+eq Cxz5OP0ukWxUdoWBBW6ZFBuTWXRNu0v36cpvklTvNrxoBMgZC7ZebrE/7mJCLJQ1 fx4CvrxIK5BdUVcxh6y9nGnUbyMEByUNEfBHJobtrp0FI6gASUzZPV7sLdkgAJUF uxmCvoO0xtqVVuOBJjCVsSpN/c+nZ5MCVqrM5DJYBNRk0ewNYH6/DrHmT4nFuHHS Hjj9vOCVSj2+/z4SL01tV4sUk1pVtyrJY7Gbm3oPveZuTNj+s4tY7+Mrt6Yg+8F6 cMvjM/FCOoaUqZRpK4Iw2BxKTVblkOomUwRplwQuVtaAVjJc2AwSsEup++mb5au0 m4Ayadv/tWr8Y1kszJ6EZ7GVALWKcbGzvR/MnHk+2p6xJwCDIjgWOFpODtuHmOVU 69bF86TDX9T9BuIhKCFVyc+ydLiWNI1qXWTTOX3kea1U1WXl1+WL2rcvFJdMogSQ VEmOA/+It3jaZWLoja5op/5RaxLK+9KtMVjj4XzGWZG3aVL0DNHmLgXdKmBEAn/T DFH939Tt8Gh9KqLfF1Lwg/CcFOfA2W97pB2KqkPK+xK9ybIlruwZk3feJ+/WOcl4 JkEbbqZt1OkEzxbX8xBOel3VnqBAPaBikz0ikpMhNslVVcrewVk8IEezRgAxAeeH YXWhC+7m7QNaT9/x3JMLPhTL7QhtQ0AUUaks =VuoR -----END PGP PUBLIC KEY BLOCK----- --------------020806020003070609090405--